Reviews
This is a beautiful house in a stunning location. The house is one of a kind. Even on a wintery November week the lake was beautiful. We stayed very comfortably in this elegant house. Plenty of room to sleep, read and watch TV. I would love to go back in the warmer months. I can’t think of a better lake vacation with lots of family. Nov 2023
The Sheldrake House is a beautiful historic home. The location is quiet and peaceful. The boathouse with kayaks, lovely outdoor covered seating, firepit, beach, and hammock was an extra bonus. Everyone enjoyed the sunrises and sunsets and the peaceful sound of Cayuga Lake. The inside of the home is immaculate, and the furnishing is fantastic. There was plenty of space for our family to hang out and celebrate my Dad's birthday and the life of my Mom. O'Malleys was a great little bar and restaurant right by the house. We enjoyed going there, and I also recommend the Finger Lakes Cider House. Oct 2023
Great location with access to the water. The area is really peaceful. House was great for a large group. We all enjoyed our stay here and would return. Jennifer was really responsive and helpful. Aug 2023
The Sheldrake House is absolutely beautiful. It is a historic home that is well maintained and has all the amenities we could ask for. Jennifer was great to communicate with and made sure we felt at home. The views of the lake from the house are beyond description. I would definitely stay here again. June 2023
This was maybe the nicest house on a lake I have ever rented. Absolutely fantastic and I could not recommend it enough. June 2023
Perfect place to reunite with family and friends. Jennifer is an amazing host who thought of everything. Definitely recommend the Sheldrakehouse as your Finger Lake destination. June 2023
Jennifer's home was perfect for our family celebration of our son's graduation. It's conveniently located just outside of Ithaca. The home has an amazing view and access to Cayuga Lake. We were all able to kayak and canoe from the boat house which was awesome and the dock was perfect for us to get on and off the pontoon boat that we rented just down the road from the house. The accommodations had everything we needed. We highly recommend this house for a family gathering! May 2023
This was our first time in the Fingerlakes and it was spectacular! Staying at The Sheldrake House was the most peaceful stay we have ever had! This home was situated perfectly on the shoreline of Lake Cayuga because there is only a slight decline to the water’s edge and the boat house was the icing on the cake! We would go back in a heartbeat! Thank you Jennifer for maintaining your home so nicely! May 2023
Absolutely beautiful home in a perfect location ( but you will never want to leave)! The entire place was clean and beautiful decorated! Awesome home for a family gathering! We will be returning ! By Elizabeth O 9/5/22.
"Great spot and house! We had a great time at the Lake! Great house and set up for the kids. Rent a boat for the week!" By John P 7/27/2021.
"We had an amazing time, the location and house was just as we expected! Will definitely be back!" By Sibia M. 6/30/2021.
"We recently stayed here for a long weekend visit to the finger lakes. The house was wonderful and perfect for two families staying there with plenty of space for kids and adults. The setting was beautiful - the kids enjoyed playing on the lake. Overall a great house in a wonderful setting." By Anonymous 6/26/2021.
"Sheldrake estate is a beautiful property! Our family explored the Finger Lakes and had dinner together every night. What's not to love?" By Martin M Springfield, OH 4/8/2021.
"A beautiful classic house on Cayuga Lake near Sheldrake Point. The rooms are big and vey nice. The kitchen is a gem, as are the porches and patio areas Easy access to the lake. Swimming and fishing are both excellent. Public boat launch is nearby. We had a fabulous family vacation!" By John 4/12/2021.